VSXUL
← Notes

Goods Are Getting Cheaper. Why Is It Getting Harder to Make Money?

/13 min read/ 0 reads

I don't know when it started, but the malls that used to be busy gradually became quiet.

The milk tea shop on the first floor still had a line. The clothing store on the second floor had few customers. Restaurants that used to require waiting for a table now had empty seats at mealtime.

Some familiar shops quietly closed and were replaced by new signs. A few months later, the new shops were gone too.

The mall is still there, but the people seem to be disappearing.

What is more puzzling is that people have not stopped spending.

Delivery packages still pile up at pickup stations. Food-delivery riders still weave through the city. Products in livestreams keep selling.

On one side, consumption is becoming more convenient and cheaper. On the other, physical businesses are becoming harder to run.

What exactly happened in between?

01Restaurant revenue is still growing. Why do restaurants keep closing?

Let's look at some numbers.

Data from the National Bureau of Statistics shows that in the first three quarters of 2026, national retail sales of consumer goods reached 37 trillion yuan, up 1.1% year on year.

Catering revenue was 4.1969 trillion yuan, up 2.4% year on year.

In other words, according to national statistics, people have not stopped eating out, and the catering market as a whole is still growing.

But on the other side, the operating pressure on the restaurant industry is very obvious.

A 2026 report by the Red Food Industry Research Institute, based on its monitoring data, found that more than 3 million restaurant stores closed nationwide in 2025, and the institute estimated that the average lifespan of a restaurant had shortened to around 15 months.

It is important to note that the "closures" counted by industry institutions are not exactly the same as deregistration of businesses, and the number of closed stores cannot be directly understood as a net decrease in stores, because new stores keep opening.

But it at least shows one thing:

The turnover rate of restaurant stores is very high, and it is increasingly difficult for an ordinary restaurant to survive in the long term.

The same change is appearing in shopping malls.

CBRE's Q3 2026 report shows that the retail property vacancy rate in the markets it covers was 7.5%, and first-floor rents at shopping centers fell 1.3% cumulatively in the first three quarters.

If shops were still in short supply, landlords would normally have no reason to keep cutting rents.

Falling rents reflect precisely that some businesses' ability to pay is weakening.

Of course, not all physical stores are declining.

In the first three quarters of 2026, sales at convenience stores and supermarkets above the designated size grew 5.2% and 4.1%, respectively, while department stores and brand specialty stores fell 2.9% and 10.3%.

This set of data reveals an important change:

It is not that consumers no longer need offline commerce, but that more and more traditional physical stores have lost the reason they originally existed.

02E-commerce did not just eliminate middlemen

Go back twenty years.

A product made in a factory might pass through regional agents, wholesalers, and distributors before finally reaching a street-level retailer.

At every step, a layer of price was added.

From the consumer's perspective, this was clearly inefficient.

E-commerce changed all of this.

Factories could sell directly to consumers, warehousing and logistics operated centrally, and prices gradually became transparent.

Something that used to cost 100 yuan might now cost 80.

Consumers saved money, and factories might sell more.

This is certainly economic progress.

But one thing is often overlooked.

The original agents, wholesalers, and retailers were not just middlemen earning a price spread.

They also rented offices, hired employees, bought equipment, and paid transportation costs.

Store clerks received wages and went out to eat.

Restaurant owners made money and hired people to renovate.

Renovation workers earned income and spent it at other shops.

These not-especially-efficient commercial links actually supported a large amount of dispersed employment and income.

When e-commerce shortens the channel, some of the original profit naturally disappears or shifts to brands, platforms, warehousing, logistics, and marketing service providers.

This shift is not necessarily harmful.

If new industries create more high-income jobs, and the money consumers save becomes new spending, society as a whole may become wealthier.

The problem is:

Can the traditional jobs being eliminated be replaced in time by new jobs with higher incomes?

If not, some regions may see a phenomenon in which commercial efficiency rises while residents' employment and income come under pressure.

This is also why we cannot look only at whether goods are cheaper, but also at whether ordinary people have opportunities to keep earning.

03Food delivery deserves more attention, because it may not shorten the commercial chain

Food delivery is not exactly the same as e-commerce.

In the past, when we wanted to eat, we had to walk to a restaurant.

Now we order through a platform, the restaurant cooks, and a rider delivers it to our home.

The production stage has not obviously decreased; instead, digital platforms and last-mile delivery have been added.

What food delivery really changed is two things:

First, consumers no longer need to go to the restaurant themselves.

Second, the way restaurants acquire customers has changed.

In the past, whether a restaurant could make money depended largely on location, taste, service, and word of mouth among nearby residents.

Now, platform rankings, exposure, promotional subsidies, and user reviews can also affect orders.

Restaurants used to pay rent mainly to landlords in exchange for offline foot traffic.

Now they also have to consider platform service fees, delivery fees, and online marketing costs.

To some extent, online traffic costs are becoming another form of rent.

More important is price competition.

When two restaurants do business on the same street, customers will at least consider distance, atmosphere, service, and taste.

But on a delivery platform, price becomes especially visible.

For the same rice bowl dish, one sells for 25 yuan, while another costs only 15 yuan after subsidies.

It is hard for consumers not to be influenced.

To get orders, merchants may be forced to join discount campaigns.

The problem is that a restaurant's ingredients, labor, and rent do not fall in step with the selling price.

In June 2026, when the State Administration for Market Regulation sought public comments on the "Ten Rules for Regulating Food-Delivery Platform Subsidies (Draft for Comment)," it explicitly pointed out that food-delivery platforms had problems such as competing on subsidies, competing on price, and controlling traffic, which could harm the interests of merchants, riders, and consumers.

This means that irrational competition on delivery platforms is no longer merely a commercial dispute among merchants.

However, we cannot ignore the new value created by food delivery.

It has indeed expanded the service range of some restaurants, created delivery jobs, and generated new demand among consumers who previously had no time to visit a restaurant.

So what we really need to oppose is not food delivery itself, but the situation in which merchants are forced to sacrifice reasonable profits and join endless low-price competition.

Platforms create trading opportunities, and they should profit by improving transaction efficiency, not mainly by continuously squeezing the survival space of merchants to sustain competition.

04When one shop closes, an entire street can be affected

Imagine a commercial street with 100 shops.

Every day, people come to buy clothes, eat, get haircuts, and repair phones.

These needs are connected.

Someone buys clothes and then has a cup of coffee.

Someone gets a haircut and then eats nearby.

These seemingly unrelated shops actually share the same group of customers.

In economics, this can be understood as the positive externality of commercial agglomeration.

Simply put, the existence of one shop can bring extra foot traffic to others.

Now the situation has changed.

Clothes can be bought online, lunch can be delivered, and many daily necessities can arrive the same day.

Consumers do not need to go out specifically, and other spending that might have happened along the way decreases.

When a clothing store closes, the loss is not just the revenue from selling clothes.

It may reduce foot traffic at the coffee shop next door, make the surrounding shops less attractive, and even affect the landlord's rental income.

If store closures become concentrated enough, a cycle may form:

Foot traffic falls, and merchant profits decline.

Merchants close, and the commercial street becomes less attractive.

Shops sit vacant, and nearby service businesses are affected.

Employment and operating income fall, further reducing local residents' spending power.

Not every street will go through this process.

But in areas lacking new industries, new jobs, and new consumption scenarios, it can certainly happen.

This also explains why a city's growing online transaction volume does not mean every commercial street will prosper.

The platform economy can break through geographic limits, but the decline of physical commerce may be concentrated in specific neighborhoods.

05The problem is not just that business is being taken away; consumers are also becoming more cautious

If we blame all the problems on e-commerce and food delivery, we will overlook another important factor.

Residents' own willingness to spend.

In the first three quarters of 2026, national per capita disposable income grew 5.3% in nominal terms year on year, but per capita consumption expenditure grew only 3.6%.

Income growing faster than consumption expenditure does not automatically mean residents are broadly afraid to spend, because savings, debt repayment, demographic structure, and other factors also affect the gap.

But at least we can see that income growth has not been fully converted into current consumption.

In addition, the median national per capita disposable income was 28,388 yuan, lower than the average of 34,230 yuan.

This reminds us that average income does not represent the budget an ordinary family can actually control.

For many families, consumption decisions depend not only on how much money is in the bank account today.

They also depend on whether work will be stable next year, whether the mortgage can be repaid comfortably, and how much must be set aside for children's education and elderly care.

If people lack confidence in future income, even cheaper goods may not make them willing to spend more.

A piece of clothing that used to sell for 300 yuan now sells for 200.

Consumers may feel they have saved 100 yuan.

But they may not spend that 100 yuan on dinner; they may simply save it.

This creates another contradiction:

Businesses want to cut prices to get more orders, while consumers want to cut spending to feel safer.

As a result, prices keep falling, profits keep thinning, and the market does not boom as expected.

In the first three quarters of 2026, national real estate development investment fell 20.6% year on year, and private investment fell 10.4%.

The relationship among the real estate adjustment, business expectations, and employment confidence cannot be ignored.

The problems facing China's offline physical commerce today are not caused by a single channel.

They are simultaneously affected by changes in the consumption structure, intensifying commercial competition, the real estate adjustment, and shifts in income expectations.

06The real way out is not to make consumers accept high prices again

At this point, a question naturally arises:

Should we restrict e-commerce and reduce food delivery to protect physical stores and make consumers return to the past?

I think this is neither realistic nor necessary.

Efficiency gains from technological progress should not be reversed.

What really needs to change is how profits and income are distributed after efficiency improves, and how traditional physical commerce can find new ways to survive.

First, commercial operating costs should reflect reality.

Rents should reflect actual foot traffic and merchants' ability to pay.

If foot traffic on a commercial street has already fallen, but landlords still charge rents based on the most prosperous period in the past, the result can only be more vacant shops.

Rather than leaving a shop empty for six months, it is better to use more flexible rents, revenue-sharing, and short-term leases to let small businesses with potential enter.

Second, platform competition should shift from price to service.

Regulation should focus on forced promotions, opaque fees, unfair traffic allocation, and similar practices, so merchants can clearly calculate how much they actually earn from an order.

Platform service fees are not inherently a sin, and reasonable profit is not either.

What must be avoided is a situation in which merchants, platforms, and riders all fail to gain sustainable returns from long-term low-price competition.

Third, we need to rethink the value of physical stores.

If a physical store is only responsible for putting standardized factory goods on shelves, it will find it hard to beat e-commerce in the long run.

E-commerce is better at displaying massive selections, comparing prices, and centralizing delivery.

But dining experiences, on-site service, repairs, sports, parent-child activities, and social gatherings all have value that must be realized in a physical space.

The physical stores of the future may no longer be merely places for commodity transactions, but carriers of experience, service, and community relationships.

This does not mean that adding a few experience projects can save a shopping mall.

Operators still have to answer the most practical questions: Why must customers come here? How often are they willing to come? How much do they spend each time? Can that revenue cover costs?

Finally, and most importantly: let ordinary families feel safe enough to spend again.

Short-term coupons can bring some consumption forward.

But in the long run, stable employment, predictable income, and more secure social services are the foundation for sustained consumption growth.

If a family is always worried about unemployment, retirement, and medical expenses, even cheaper goods will struggle to sustain the desire to spend.

Instead of constantly studying how to make consumers spend more, we should first study how to give consumers more money they can spend with confidence.

07We may be living through a redistribution of commercial wealth

Zoom out a little.

In the past, commercial opportunities were largely dispersed across geographic space.

A street, a county town, a community—each had its own merchants, customers, and commercial relationships.

This system was not necessarily efficient, but it provided livelihoods for a large number of ordinary families.

Today, digital platforms let goods and services break through geographic limits.

A leading merchant can sell nationwide, while an ordinary street shop may not even be able to retain orders from nearby residents.

Competition is no longer just between two shops across the street.

It may be a mom-and-pop shop competing on the same screen with thousands of merchants across the country.

This will certainly improve efficiency, but it may also further concentrate traffic, scale advantages, and profits among a small number of operators.

However, concentration is not inevitable.

The same technology can also let small shops without marketing capabilities reach new customers, and let producers in remote areas sell directly.

What determines the outcome is not only technology, but also the rules of market competition, workers' bargaining power, social security, and how newly created commercial value is distributed among participants.

A more efficient commercial system should let society obtain more goods and services at lower cost.

But a more prosperous economic system also needs enough people to have stable incomes and be willing to keep spending.

These two things are not naturally the same.

Closing thoughts

Perhaps the cities of the future really will not need as many clothing stores, department stores, and traditional retail outlets as before.

Some business models being eliminated is an unavoidable result of technological progress.

We do not have to ask consumers to give up cheaper, more convenient ways of living just to preserve memories of busy streets.

But we should not simply attribute every closed business to a lack of effort or poor management.

When a large number of people simultaneously feel that business is getting harder, when consumers grow accustomed to low prices but also increasingly worry about their own incomes, this is no longer merely the operating problem of one shop.

Commerce has never been only about buying and selling.

One person's spending is another person's income.

One person's income supports the next purchase.

If every company is trying to cut costs, and every consumer is trying to spend less, who will create the next round of growth?

I think this is the question most worth thinking about seriously behind the downturn in physical commerce.

What we really need is not necessarily a return to an era of more expensive goods and longer channels.

It is to let the wealth created by technological progress turn into broader employment, more stable incomes, and more confident consumption.

After all, the prosperity of a society should not be reflected only in goods becoming cheaper and cheaper.

It should also be reflected in ordinary people being able to live better lives through their own work.

Sources

  1. National Bureau of Statistics of China — "Retail sales of consumer goods grew 1.1% in January–September 2026" (October 19, 2026)
    https://www.stats.gov.cn/sj/zxfb/202610/t20261019_1965614.html
  2. National Bureau of Statistics of China — "Household income and consumption expenditure in the first three quarters of 2026" (October 19, 2026)
    https://www.stats.gov.cn/sj/zxfbhjd/202610/t20261019_1965612.html
  3. National Bureau of Statistics of China — "The economy operated steadily in the first three quarters, with new progress in high-quality development" (October 19, 2026)
    https://www.stats.gov.cn/sj/zxfb/202610/t20261019_1965618.html
  4. CBRE — "China Real Estate Market Report — Q3 2026" (October 29, 2026)
    https://www.cbre.com.cn/insights/figures/中国房地产市场报告-2026年第三季度
  5. Red Food Industry Research Institute — "Research Report on Cost Reduction and Efficiency Innovation in Food Service 2026" (March 2026)
    https://pdf.dfcfw.com/pdf/H3_AP202603121820527459_1.pdf
  6. State Administration for Market Regulation — news on the "Ten Rules for Regulating Food-Delivery Platform Subsidies (Draft for Comment)" (June 17, 2026)
    https://www.samr.gov.cn/zt/ndzt/2025n/zhzznjsjzwhgpjzsczx/zjbs/art/2026/art_5a4d1c0322b14c25a15399a0b2fe3c8f.html

Note: National Bureau of Statistics data are official statistics. Restaurant closure counts and average lifespan are industry monitoring estimates with different statistical definitions and cannot be directly equated with business deregistration data. The discussion of economic transmission mechanisms and possible paths forward is analysis based on the above evidence, not a proven single causal conclusion.

← Notes